There is much ado lately about the Susquehanna River smallmouth bass fishery.
This is one of the most complex issues I've seen raised, and depending on who you talk to, you get opinions from one extreme to the other. There are differing viewpoints from various fisheries researchers with masters and doctorate degrees, all the way down to the casual angler with a pocket full of sinkers and a box of nightcrawlers.
On one hand we keep hearing about water quality issues, while on the other hand, most of us who grew up on the river know it looks nicer now than it did 30 or 40 years ago. You have to wonder why there is a problem with the smallmouth when the rest of the fish seem to be doing OK.
Another indicator of water quality is insect life. From my casual, non-scientific observations, insect life is thriving. Lift any rock and you will see lots of activity. There are tremendous hatches coming off the river throughout the seasons.
Another issue involved is public perception. At one end you have people who quit fishing and won't even swim in the river. At the other end you have people who practically live in the river and catch lots of fish.
I had a booth at the Butler Sports Show two years ago near Pittsburgh. People in that area were surprised to learn that there were any fish left in the Susquehanna. All they had heard was that it was an "endangered" river with all kinds of problems. They were quite surprised when I showed them pictures of 40-inch plus muskie and 3- to 4-pound smallmouths.
Then you have to think about the fishermen. There are those who are quite OK with the way things are now in relation to the smallmouth situation. They may not be catching as many all the time as they used to, but they are catching more quality-size fish than ever. Newcomers to the sport are especially quite impressed at times with the smallmouth this river produces.
Then there are the experienced river anglers who are struggling to catch any bass now. Creel surveys have shown that most bass fishermen release their fish, but there are anglers who kill smallmouth to eat. The creel surveys I was included in were at major boat ramps during the summer. I see far more smallmouth harvested at places like Shady Nook and the Norry Point during the spring and fall. They are doing absolutely nothing illegal. They are lawfully allowed to kill whatever the legal limit is.
Eating fish is part of the sport of fishing, a fact that escapes some. As long as the Fish Commission stands by the view that anglers cannot affect the population, there is nothing illegal or unethical about killing smallmouth.
Herein lies the problem, because to many concerned river smallmouth anglers, eating a smallmouth would be like eating your dog. If the smallmouth population is down, as statistics and experience has shown, shouldn't we try to preserve what's left? What if the harvest estimates are wrong?
Whatever they do will not in a million years please everyone. Whether you are catch-and-kill, catch-and-release, pro-tournament or anti-tournament, or some combination of the above, you will probably have a burr under your saddle sooner or later.
The good thing is that the gears are finally now turning, however slowly, on getting something done.
n Ken Maurer, Herndon, is a licensed guide and a regular contributor to the Outdoors section. Email comments to kenrose@tds.net
Sports
Ken Maurer's Inside Line column: Smallmouth bass are a big topic
- Sports
-
-
Defense helps Crusaders snap skid
The going hasn't been easy for the Susquehanna University women's basketball team this season. So much so, that it hasn't won a game in more than a month.
-
SU rides Harley to win
With the chants of "ride the Harley" coming from the student body, sophomore Harley Sellinger certainly took visiting Goucher for a spin Friday night.
-
HS Roundup: Braves close in on playoff bid
Counted for dead not too long ago, the Shikellamy Braves are still alive and kicking and they are now one win away from making the District 4 playoffs.
-
Danville stays in HAC-I title race
When their 13-point lead had been whittled to seven midway through the fourth quarter Friday, the Danville girls were at a tipping point.
-
Harold Raker's column on high school wrestling: Playing the name game
Going into last weekend, with four Valley teams competing in the District 4 Class AA and AAA Duals Tournament, I had already made tentative plans to be in Hershey this week. Had things gone really well, I would have still been in Chocolatetown, covering at least one of them in the state tournament.
-
NCAA denies UConn APR waiver request
The NCAA on Friday turned down the University of Connecticut's request for a waiver that would allow its men's basketball team to play in the 2013 national championship tournament.
-
College Lacrosse: Bucknell men prepare to improve upon great season
LEWISBURG -- It started a handful of years ago, when the Bucknell men's lacrosse team put a big 'X' on the national map in Central Pennsylvania with an upset of No. 1 Maryland. From that point on Bison coach Frank Fedorjaka has had a difficult time getting big-time opponents on the schedule, even with Bucknell opting to travel under the worst of circumstances.
-
High school football: Pratt says Kutztown the right fit
SUNBURY -- When Shikellamy's Tyler Pratt joins the Kutztown University football team as a free safety next fall, he will already have a good feeling for what his position coach will expect from him. Pratt, who signed a national letter of intent this week to accept a scholarship offer to play for the Golden Bears, will be under the tutelage of his father's high school football coach.
-
Todd Stanford On high school boys basketball: Increasing the refs' workload
If two heads are better than one, does that mean six eyes are better than four? Not necessarily, according to some Heartland Athletic Conference officials. There is a move afoot in the HAC to cut the number of basketball referees from three to two for part of the season beginning next year.
-
High School Roundup: Greenwood boys complete perfect TVL season
Greenwood capped off an unbeaten 2011-12 Tri-Valley League season by crushing Halifax 61-38 on Thursday Night.
- More Sports Headlines
-
Defense helps Crusaders snap skid
