The Pennsylvania Game Commission, at the urging of Commissioner Russ Schleiden, is investigating the possibility of legalizing the use of crossbows during the archery deer seasons. It should come as no surprise that "traditional" archery hunters are rising up in protest.
I wouldn't be one to run right out and buy a crossbow if they were legal in archery season; grouse and woodcock are on my mind at that time of year, and I have no problem with archery hunters wanting to protect their private time in the woods.
I wouldn't be crazy about having more hunters in the woods at that time of year, either. However, I do feel that the bow hunters have, from what I've seen, been reluctant to state their real objections. These are a few I've seen that, in my opinion, miss the mark:
Argument No.1: A crossbow is not really a bow and is far too effective. However, I'm sure that bow hunters of old would have the same comment about the current crop of compound bows with all their pulleys, balancing rods, sophisticated sights and such. It all depends on where you draw the line with regard to technical innovation.
Argument No. 2: Archery hunting should be difficult; the challenge is what makes bow hunting special. However, you could argue that bow hunting would remain just as challenging for the hunter who decides to continue using a regular bow. For him, nothing would change, except for the possibility of more hunters in the woods.
Argument No. 3: The only people pushing to legalize crossbows are crossbow manufacturers. That seems to be true, but one can't fault manufacturers for trying to open new markets, can one? Seems to me that's what all successful business enterprises do. Does anyone doubt that compound bow manufacturers are constantly looking to expand archery seasons across the nation, thereby opening new markets for their products?
Argument No. 4: If crossbows are legalized during archery season, large numbers of people will buy one and head for the woods during the archery season, making the woods much more crowded. It remains to be seen, but they may very well be right about that one.
Normally I don't like to see hunters fighting against other hunters, but in this case, it's more like hunters fighting equipment manufacturers. There doesn't seem to be great numbers of hunters clamoring to legalize crossbows during archery season.
Which brings us to what I believe are would be valid arguments against the legalization effort:
Argument No. 1: The PGC should be basing its decisions on the desires of actual "stakeholders," which includes hunters, not on the desires of equipment manufacturers.
Argument No. 2: The difficulty of bow hunting, and the skill involved, along with the solitude, make bow hunting a truly special sport deserving a special, exclusive, season of its own. Many bow hunters adopted the sport to escape the crowds of the firearms season. Traditional bow hunters shouldn't be asked to share the woods with the multitude of new hunters the legalization of crossbows might bring.
Argument No. 3: If crossbows were allowed during archery season, would we have to have a special classification in the record books for trophy animals shot with a crossbow, or would it be fair for them to be listed as merely "archery" kills? A complication we don't need.
Archery hunters shouldn't be ashamed to say that they don't care to share the woods with able-bodied crossbow hunters. It may sound selfish to some, but it's the truth.
n Don Steese, of Northumberland, writes a weekly column for The Daily Item. E-mail comments to jdsteese@yahoo.com.
Sports
Don Steese's Outdoor Perspectives column: Archers up in arms over crossbows
- Sports
-
-
Scott Dudinskie's column on girls basketball: They learn to be tough young
It's difficult to recall exactly how the sequence unfolded because it happened so darn fast.
-
Motorsports: Selinsgrove, Lincoln speedways to host 360 sprint series
Mach 1 Chassis of Mechanicsburg will be the title sponsor of the Mid-Atlantic 360 Sprint Car Championship Series, a $120,000 six-race tour that will include five shows at Selinsgrove Speedway and one event at Lincoln Speedway in 2012.
-
Girls basketball: Records fall, Red Tornadoes stay unbeaten
n overflow crowd zealously cheered Tierney Pfirman's pursuit of the South Williamsport scoring record throughout Tuesday's game, until their breathless faces matched the Mounties' royal blue.
- High school roundup: Rosini pin lifts Ironmen over Tigers
-
College sports notebook: Antensteiner starts, finishes fast
ANVILLE -- Ines Antensteiner, a member of the powerful Lewisburg girls track & field team for the past four seasons wasted little time making her presence felt in college. On Monday, Antensteiner, a freshman at Lebanon Valley, was named the Middle Atlantic Conference's Indoor Track & Field Athlete of the Week after a pair of event wins at Saturday's Ducharme Invitational.
-
Bill Bowman's column on college sports: Tale of two teams in the clutch
Because basketball season is so long it is easy to forget that one or two moments in a single game can essentially make or break an entire season. While teams might play 30 games or so, most of them come down to a couple of possessions, spots where one little thing can be the difference between winning and losing, between making the postseason tournament or turning in the uniforms.
-
Sports court strips Contador of 2010 Tour title
MADRID -- Alberto Contador was stripped of his 2010 Tour de France title Monday and banned for two years after sports' highest court found the Spanish cyclist guilty of doping. The Court of Arbitration for Sport suspended the three-time Tour champion after rejecting his claim that his positive test for clenbuterol was caused by eating contaminated meat on a 2010 Tour rest day.
-
H.S. boys basketball: Selinsgrove rallies to top Southern Columbia
CATAWISSA -- In a battle between two schools better known for their football programs, Monday's game between host Southern Columbia and Selinsgrove naturally featured plenty of physical play. After a combined 43 fouls and 55 free-throw attempts, the Seals finally pulled it out. Reserve guard Tyler Krebs made five foul shots in the final minute and a half in Selinsgrove's 54-53 victory.
-
High School Bowling: Kratzer, Hartranft take home Pro-Am titles
SUNBURY -- The name might have changed, but the results were the same. Now called the 13th annual Best Bowl/Strike Zone High School Pro-Am Scholarship Challenge, the two-day tournament was another success as it pitted some of the Valley's best young bowlers against each other in friendly competition.
-
High School Roundup: Even without Andreychik, Danville boys cruise
DANVILLE -- Playing without recent 1,000-point scorer Andrew Andreychik -- who was out sick -- Danville extended its winning streak to 17 games by putting four players in double figures in a 68-32 Heartland Athletic Conference crossover win over Central Columbia on Monday.
- More Sports Headlines
-
Scott Dudinskie's column on girls basketball: They learn to be tough young
