Right about now is when the Heisman talk really heats up. When the calendar flips to November, BCS talk starts to boil and pundits from coast to coast argue the merits of their candidate as the best player in the nation.
Perhaps in no other season has the race been as wide open as it is this year, which is a big, big surprise. Consider that two Heisman winners were back this year (Tim Tebow and Sam Bradford) and Texas' Colt McCoy was thought by many to have been jobbed of the trophy a year ago.
Conventional wisdom was that one of those three would win it.
If Bradford was not eliminated on opening night when he went down with an injury against BYU, he certainly was a few weeks later when got hurt on the first series of the Red River Rivalry and is now out for the season.
Both McCoy and Tebow have good seasons, just not the kind of seasons they've had in the past. Their numbers are down, but they are still considered frontrunners.
Others to throw their name into the mix include Alabama tailback Mark Ingram, Notre Dame's Jimmy Clausen and Golden Tate and a host of others like Houston QB Case Keenum and even Nebraska defensive tackle Ndamukong Suh (pronounced just like it looks: Joe Smith).
But no one has really established himself as the favorite. So I will offer the following, which while it certainly won't swing your opinion, I hope at least gets another name into the conversation.
Here are the actual statistics of three quarterbacks, including their team's record:
Player A: 99-of-153 passing (65 percent) with four interceptions, 1,323 yards and 10 TDs. Also 551 yards rushing and another 8 scores. Team is unbeaten, 8-0 and ranked in the top 10
Player B: 166-of-263 passing (63 percent) with seven interceptions, 2,158 yards and 18 TDs. Also 148 yards rushing and 5 TDs. Team is 8-1 and ranked in the top 15.
Player C: 198-of-275 passing (72 percent) with eight interceptions, 1,977 yards and 15 TDs. Also 113 yards rushing and a TD. Team is unbeaten, 8-0 and ranked in the top 10.
Which player deserves the Heisman? Depends on how you look at it. If your equation is the best player on the best team, then it's going to be either A or C.
If it is based on the player with best stats on a really good team, then B at least has to get tossed into the equation.
Problem is everybody is talking about Player A (Tim Tebow) and Player C (Colt McCoy), but nobody is talking about Player B, Penn State quarterback Daryll Clark.
Save for one bad half (and for those who suffered through it, it was about as bad as bad gets) against Iowa, Clark has been outstanding all season. He threw for better than 2,500 yards a year ago, the third best total in school history. And with three regular season games, plus a bowl game, remaining, he has a shot at Kerry Collins' school record of 2,679.
You remember Kerry Collins right? The same guy who was fourth in the Heisman voting in 1994, the guy who may have won if not for splitting votes with backfield mate Ki-Jana Carter. Yeah, that's the guy who Clark is about to erase from the record books.
Clark is a decent game away from 5,000 career passing yards, amazing considering he is in his second season as a starter. It's even more amazing when you consider that he's done it with two virtually different receiving corps. A year ago he was the conductor of Penn State's new Spread-HD offense, slinging it to Derrick Williams, Deon Butler and Jordan Norwood. All of them now are gone and he hasn't missed a beat, now finding people like Derek Moye, Graham Zug and Chaz Powell.
Do I think Clark has a shot to win the Heisman? The second half of the Iowa game pretty much took him out of the running. But he should at least be in the discussion because no player on any team in the nation means as much to his team as Clark does to Penn State (remember a true freshman is Penn State's backup QB).
The senior gets another chance on a big stage Saturday when he leads the Nittany Lions against his home-state team, Ohio State, at what is sure to be a rowdy Beaver Stadium on Saturday afternoon. His counterpart will be Terrelle Pryor, one of the nation's biggest recruits two years ago, a Pa. native who spurned Happy Valley for Columbus.
If Clark has a good day, his name should at least be part of the conversation when it comes to who is the best player in college football.
n Sports editor Bill Bowman covers college football for The Daily Item. E-mail comments to bbowman@dailyitem.com.
Sports
Williams Bowman's college football column: Does Clark have Heisman potential?
- Sports
-
-
H.S. Track & Field notebook: Better late than never
As soon as the Class AA boys javelin throwers were finished Friday morning, Lewisburg’s Brandon Smith left his fellow competitors at the throwing area and took off for Seth Grove Stadium track, trying to hurry while negotiating the heavy foot traffic of fans, coaches and athletes.
-
Keller runs to his first victory
Amazing. That was the simple reply from Cody Keller after capping the long comeback from injury win his first sprint car race Saturday night at Selinsgrove Speedway.
-
Zaktansky: Life lessons learned from an earthworm
On my hands and knees, I slogged forward.
The steady rain had long before soaked through my clothes and turned the ground underneath me into a slick film of runny mud. My back hurt, my fingers were caked with brown goop and my mouth was aching from holding a small flashlight as I slowly scanned the backyard. -
Indigo buntings grace the Valley
Summer is the best time for viewing a spectrum of colorful birds.
Like most bird species, it is the male who exhibits bright coloration. From the orange and black patterns of the northern oriole to the scarlet tanager and yellow warbler and the rose-breasted grosbeak — all make a spectacle of themselves. -
Don Steese column: Counting the days
Memorial Day weekend is traditionally the start of the summer vacation season. Kids are out school, the weather is beautiful and all is well with the world ... except for folks like myself, who find themselves counting the days until fall.
-
Hartley, Billas fight off heat
Melanie Hartley was drained, a puddle of nerves and perspiration after a brutal 400-meter dash. While the official thermometer at Shippensburg University flirted with 90 degrees on Saturday, the heavy dose of humidity had the packed house at Seth Grove Stadium sweltering.
-
Moore bags two medals
Matt Moore is a hard guy to please. Or at least, he finds it hard to take pleasure in his own track and field performances.
-
Ken Maurer column: More talk about bass
This past week I attended 2 meetings involving the PFBC.
The first was in Harrisburg where fish commission officials explained to the state senators why they want the DEP to place the Susquehanna River on the “impaired” list. DEP has refused once, and the PFBC has reapplied. -
Scott Dudinskie's high school baseball column: Reich still going strong
Bryan Reich feels it with every pitch he throws. Some would call it pain, maybe discomfort. The Milton right-hander chooses "annoyance."
-
State Track & Field updates
Get updates throughout the day on how Valley athletes are faring at the PIAA Track & Field Championships in Shippensburg.
- More Sports Headlines
-
H.S. Track & Field notebook: Better late than never
