Just when I was beginning to think that many Keystone State deer hunters were resigning themselves to the reality of fewer deer, we have a mass protest scheduled for today at the Pennsylvania Game Commission headquarters in Harrisburg.
Perhaps this season was so bad for so many that the fires have again been fanned, or maybe I’ve just not been around as many dissatisfied hunters lately. As I’ve stated before, we also had a lousy deer season this year but I also had to admit that we perhaps didn’t hunt as hard as we normally would. That still may be the case, but there does seem to be a lot of discontent out there.
The deer management issue is a complicated one. For years we had too many deer, now in some areas of the state, we have too few. This, in my opinion, is especially true on public land in the northern part of the state, which is also the traditional deer hunting Mecca of Pennsylvania.
Hunters hoping to see changes in the deer management program are being given fresh hope now, with two new members on the Board of Commissioners. These two are replacing two members who were supportive of a “stay the course” approach. We’ll have to wait and see how the two new commissioners will vote on deer management related issues.
Sunbury’s Tom Boop, a current commissioner, is quoted as saying he would like to see shorter concurrent/antlerless seasons, reduced antlerless license allocations, and the elimination of early senior/junior and muzzleloader seasons. The desired result could probably be achieved using any combination of those alternatives. If they slash antlerless license allocations, they lose much-needed revenue, but any meaningful change aimed at increasing deer numbers has to, in my opinion, include a reduction in the number of antlerless licenses that are issued.
The other options, shorter seasons and elimination of some specialty seasons, would perhaps allow the commission to achieve a goal of allowing the deer herd to grow without cutting the allocations quite as much, due to the fact that antlerless hunters would have less opportunity to fill a doe tag, therefore fewer does would be killed.
The PGC is facing some tough questions, just as it has been for years. The first is whether the commission’s role to serve the interests of hunters, farmers and landowners, the general public, or the state’s forest habitat, or a combination of all these? It’s probably a combination, but then they have to decide on who should be their first priority. Being a PGC commissioner is a thankless job that I wouldn’t take if it paid big bucks (pun intended). Last I checked it didn’t.
There are those who will argue, and commissioner Boop is one of them, that, if changes aren’t made, Pennsylvania will lose its decades-old deer hunting tradition. Truth be told, we’re already well on the way. If someone were to walk around the big woods of our northern tier on the first day of the firearms season they’d find a lot of hunting cabins without anyone in them. Restaurants, bars, grocery stores, gas stations, motels, sporting goods stores and other businesses that used to depend on deer hunters now depend more on snowmobilers, turkey hunters and trout fishermen. Deer season just isn’t the big deal that it used to be.
I frankly don’t see that changing much. We are going to continue to lose hunters over the long haul no matter what we do about deer management. It’s simply a fact of life. However, there are those that will argue strongly that if the current deer management program is not changed, things will be a lot worse.
-- E-mail comments to jdsteese@yahoo.com.
Sports
A season of their discontent
- Sports
-
-
Defense helps Crusaders snap skid
The going hasn't been easy for the Susquehanna University women's basketball team this season. So much so, that it hasn't won a game in more than a month.
-
SU rides Harley to win
With the chants of "ride the Harley" coming from the student body, sophomore Harley Sellinger certainly took visiting Goucher for a spin Friday night.
-
HS Roundup: Braves close in on playoff bid
Counted for dead not too long ago, the Shikellamy Braves are still alive and kicking and they are now one win away from making the District 4 playoffs.
-
Danville stays in HAC-I title race
When their 13-point lead had been whittled to seven midway through the fourth quarter Friday, the Danville girls were at a tipping point.
-
Harold Raker's column on high school wrestling: Playing the name game
Going into last weekend, with four Valley teams competing in the District 4 Class AA and AAA Duals Tournament, I had already made tentative plans to be in Hershey this week. Had things gone really well, I would have still been in Chocolatetown, covering at least one of them in the state tournament.
-
NCAA denies UConn APR waiver request
The NCAA on Friday turned down the University of Connecticut's request for a waiver that would allow its men's basketball team to play in the 2013 national championship tournament.
-
College Lacrosse: Bucknell men prepare to improve upon great season
LEWISBURG -- It started a handful of years ago, when the Bucknell men's lacrosse team put a big 'X' on the national map in Central Pennsylvania with an upset of No. 1 Maryland. From that point on Bison coach Frank Fedorjaka has had a difficult time getting big-time opponents on the schedule, even with Bucknell opting to travel under the worst of circumstances.
-
High school football: Pratt says Kutztown the right fit
SUNBURY -- When Shikellamy's Tyler Pratt joins the Kutztown University football team as a free safety next fall, he will already have a good feeling for what his position coach will expect from him. Pratt, who signed a national letter of intent this week to accept a scholarship offer to play for the Golden Bears, will be under the tutelage of his father's high school football coach.
-
Todd Stanford On high school boys basketball: Increasing the refs' workload
If two heads are better than one, does that mean six eyes are better than four? Not necessarily, according to some Heartland Athletic Conference officials. There is a move afoot in the HAC to cut the number of basketball referees from three to two for part of the season beginning next year.
-
High School Roundup: Greenwood boys complete perfect TVL season
Greenwood capped off an unbeaten 2011-12 Tri-Valley League season by crushing Halifax 61-38 on Thursday Night.
- More Sports Headlines
-
Defense helps Crusaders snap skid
