SELINSGROVE -- Universal health-care coverage: To be or not to be?
That was the question at Thursday night's program in the Degenstein Center Theater at Susquehanna University, moderated by Allan D. Sobel, director of the Arlin M. Adams Center for Law and Society.
Health care always has been a major issue in America, and under the new political regime, it has become an even bigger one with President Obama's push for change in funding and availability. Thursday night's discussion concluded the university's two-day symposium on health-care reform.
Presenting the two sides of the issue were Devon Herrick, senior fellow of the National Center for Policy Analysis, and Claudia Fegan, a board-certified internist and former president of Physicians for a National Health Program.
"I am in favor of everyone having access to health care," Herrick said. "I am opposed to the current view on how they plan to achieve universal health care."
Access to health care is problematic, the quality is inconsistent and the cost is high, Herrick said.
Last year, Americans spent $2.3 million on health care costs. The reason, he said, is because of increased longevity, the overuse of third-party payment, low cost control and less out-of-pocket payments.
Obama's proposal is for mandated health insurance, but Herrick said he believes those goals will not be achieved for several reasons. Mandated insurance is difficult to enforce, he said, and will drive up the cost of coverage and encourage special-interest groups while reducing consumer choice.
Mandated acceptance by health insurance providers would encourage Americans to wait to obtain insurance until it is needed, and mandated benefits would increase the cost for each person, even though the person may not need specific coverage, Herrick argued.
But Fegan, a proponent of single-payer health care, which means every American is covered by a government-run health-care system, said a universal health-care system is for the societal good.
There are 45.7 million Americans who are uninsured, and 50 million more who are under-insured, she said.
"The whole issue is a civil-rights issue for the 20th century," she said. Some day, if things continue as they are, she said people will be looking back and asking, "How could we have done that to 45 million people?"
Her proposal argues that access to health care is a human right, and all people should have the right to choose or change their physician. Pursuit of corporate profit and personal fortune has no place in health care, and personal medical decisions must be made by the patient, Fegan said.
Americans must agree on removing financial barriers and financial harm. "No one who gets the care they need should have to lose their home, car or dignity," she said. Also, the insurance industry should not determine who can and cannot get health care, she argued.
The two-day symposium included a keynote presentation on Wednesday by Jonathan Cohn, author of "Sick: The Untold Story of America's Health Care Crisis -- and the People Who Pay the Price," and panel discussions with professionals throughout the day Thursday.
News
Related Photos
-
Robert Inglis/The Daily Item
-
Robert Inglis
Discussion
Speakers debate need for health-care reform
- News
-
-
2 Valley schools in top 5.5% in nation
LEWISBURG — U.S. News & World Report magazine has ranked Lewisburg Area as the 15th-best academic high school in Pennsylvania and the 803rd best in the nation, according to a report released earlier this month.
-
Northumberland opts to build sewage plant
NORTHUMBERLAND — Ending months of speculation, the Northumberland Sewer Authority has voted to build a water treatment plant, at an estimated cost of $9 million, to replace the 40-year-old sewage plant at 100 Water St.
-
Mifflinburg school board OKs millage increase
MIFFLINBURG — The Mifflinburg school board Tuesday night approved raising the property tax rate to the maximum allowed under the index, equaling about a $30 increase a year for the average taxpayer.
-
Support grows for city garden
SUNBURY— More than a month after several Bucknell University students resurrected an empty city lot by transforming the land into a full-size garden, neighbors, nearby residents and now business leaders from outside Sunbury have decided to chip in by donating seeds and planting tools in order to spruce up the corner lot.
-
Stat of the Day: 21,776
Stat of the day: 21,776. That's the number of high schools evaluated nationwide by U.S. News & World Report, after which the magazine determined that Lewisburg Area High was the 803rd best in the U.S., and Selinsgrove Area, 1,187th.
-
State House approves sales-tax exemption for airplanes
HARRISBURG — A bill to exempt the purchase and maintenance of airplanes from Pennsylvania's 6 percent sales tax won a strong vote of confidence in the state House of Representatives.
-
State lawmakers consider takeover of struggling school districts
HARRISBURG — A Republican-penned bill that would pave the way for state takeovers of Pennsylvania school districts veering toward financial collapse has the support of Gov. Tom Corbett and is advancing in the Legislature.
-
Take Me Home: Yip
Yip is a young dog, best guess is Bichon/Daschund. He is friendly and loves everyone, especially anyone who will rub his belly or let him on their lap for some doggie kisses. He enjoys car rides, has done well around other dogs, cats, and kids. Housebreaking and crate training are in the works.
-
Joe Paterno earned $13.4 million pension at Penn State
STATE COLLEGE — Joe Paterno earned a state pension of $13.4 million for his 61-year coaching career at Penn State.
-
Police Log 05.22.12
A roundup of police news reported by departments across the Central Susquehanna Valley.
-
Montour County judge dismisses flooding lawsuit
DANVILLE — A Montour County judge has dismissed a case brought against Mahoning Township by residents of the Gaytowne subdivision.
-
Shamokin man who abused puppy gets house arrest
SUNBURY — A Shamokin man entered the courtroom expecting probation for his role in dumping Harper, a 15-week-old pit bull puppy, down a 30-foot bank near a Coal Township cemetery, but Northumberland County President Judge Robert Sacavage put those thoughts to rest when he and delivered a stiff sentence.
- More News Headlines
-
2 Valley schools in top 5.5% in nation
