LEWISBURG — Honeybees will die in greater numbers this year than ever before, and court fights over the chemicals some believe are killing them will continue to be a cat-and-mouse game.
That’s the opinion of Lewisburg beekeeper Dave Hackenberg, who last week was in Orlando, Fla., at the North American Beekeeping Conference with about 750 of his peers.
He’s considered by many of them, and others worldwide, as the authority on colony collapse syndrome.
That’s when an entire hive of bees dies for no apparent reason. It’s been happening since 2004, coinciding with introduction of a new kind of pesticide.
Instead of being applied on the exterior of a mature plant, the plant’s seed is coated with the pesticide, Hackenberg said. When the seed is watered, some of the pesticide gets into the soil and then is taken up into the plant in the normal growth process, just as the plant absorbs nutrients from the soil.
In this way, the pesticide becomes internal, or “systemic,” rather than applied.
Some beekeepers believe, as bees pollinate the plants, they are exposed to these pesticides and it eventually kills them.
Manufacturers of the chemicals say they are safe.
The argument played out in federal court Dec. 23 in New York in a suit brought by the National Resource Defense Council and the United States Department of Environmental Protection against Bayer CropScience.
Judge Denise Cote originally ruled that a pesticide with the active ingredient spirotetramat, manufactured by Bayer worldwide under the name Movento, must have been pulled from the market by Friday. But Bayer came back arguing the ban was based on procedure rather than science and got an extension to Feb. 16 to straighten out the paperwork with the EPA.
“We anticipate that EPA will reaffirm the registration of spirotetramat using the correct procedure,” Bayer said in a statement.
Meanwhile, bees are needed in California to pollinate crops and, Hackenberg said, they’re facing extreme shortages.
Even if the ban were restored, he said, bees will continue to die because the chemical stays in the soil for about four years. And there’s a market basket of chemicals out there.
The companies continue to alter the chemicals when their patents run out, so they will have exclusivity on the new ones.
It used to be, Hackenberg said, that a proposed new chemical would be “handed over to the great land-grant universities for testing.”
Now, he said, there’s no such research.
The EPA’s new attitude is, he said, “Just put it out there and we’ll see what happens.’’
“The chemical companies have been give a green light right through the front door,” he said.
Hackenberg met Wednesday evening with a chief toxicologist from Bayer and, not surprisingly, there was no meeting of minds.
We say we’re losing bees, Hackenberg said, and he says the science doesn’t show it.
“No,” Hackenberg said, “reality does.”
Despite the reality, however, many beekeepers don’t grapple with the science. Some are naive, Hackenberg said, and tend to believe what they are told — whether it’s mites or mold or the phases of the moon.
“They don’t understand these new systemic chemicals,” he said.
Few farmers in the Valley, he said, even know anything about the chemicals they’re using.
“If you talk to them and ask them ‘Do you know what you’re using?’ or ‘Do you know how it works?’ many will say no, they pay a crop analyst for that.
“The crop analyst goes out and looks at the crops and tells them what to use.”
Hackenberg said if you ask the crop analyst how he knows what to recommend, he’ll say the chemical companies tell him.
It was unknown whether the members of the conference, which ended Saturday night, would draft a resolution against the use of products that contain the suspect chemicals.
That’s analogous to the doctor who prescribes pills based on what the pharmaceutical sales rep tell him, he said.
Meanwhile, honeybees remain essential to about one third of all the grown food humans eat. In the United States, they pollinate 90 different agricultural crop species including nuts, berries, fruits and vegetables worth about $15 billion a year.
News
Related Photos
-
File photo
Discussion
Bee expert, chemical rep clash over pesticides
- News
-
-
Students seek smoke reprieve
Eleven-year-old Brendan Calvert stands far from his bus stop so he can get away from the cigarette smoke.
“I usually stand way back,” he said.
-
2 stabbed, 4 in custody after city melee
SUNBURY — One man was hospitalized with stab wounds, four people were in custody and arrest warrants were issued for two others following a violent confrontation early Monday morning on South 11th Street.
-
Year-long drive nets 30 packages
Primary school students kept soldiers in mind throughout the year with a donation drive that has sent more than 30 packages to local service men and women by the end of the school year.
-
Special 'Fish for Free' day gets bites
MIFFLINBURG — Lee Tyson and his son, Walter, spent a leisurely Memorial Day fishing off the pier at Halfway Lake in the Raymond B. Winter State Park in western Union County.
-
Flood-damaged covered bridge to be repaired
MONTANDON — Only 25 cars a day crossed the Rishel Covered Bridge before raging flood waters from Tropical Storm Lee pushed the 181-year-old span six inches off its foundation in September.
-
Single mom is new millionaire
DANVILLE — A single mother of three and Danville State Hospital employee reportedly learned she’s a $1 million lottery winner while visiting a local store Monday.
-
Storms pound region
A series of thunderstorms prompted flash-flood warnings across the Susquehanna Valley Sunday night.
-
Drizzle doesn't stop Mazeppa parade, service
MAZEPPA — Small-town American spirit was on display in Mazeppa at the community’s annual Memorial Day parade on Sunday.
-
Lions raffling premium tickets
Two lucky people will win Philadelphia Phillies Diamond Club seats for a September game.
-
Dial 211 matches callers, agencies
SELINSGROVE — The Union-Snyder Community Action Agency is preparing to launch Dial 211 in July, but if you call it now, it works.
-
Pastor: Some twist Scriptures for own ends
During the 2012 United Methodist Church General Conference held in Tampa, Fla., earlier this month, church leaders chose to maintain the wording in their Book of Discipline, voting down motions that would have approved same-sex marriages and the ordination of homosexual ministers.
-
Burgers, people sizzle
SUNBURY -- Under clear skies Saturday, the temperature felt like 100 degrees, more like the Fourth of July than the Memorial Day weekend, according to a meteorologist who said the sticky, stifling conditions will persist for several days.
- More News Headlines
-
