DANVILLE — A Montour County jury has cleared Geisinger Medical Center and two physicians of negligence in a civil court case involving a Shamokin woman who died following surgery eight years ago.
The jury deliberated about an hour Wednesday afternoon before reaching its verdict, according to a court spokesman.
The lawsuit filed by the family of Patrice Dupnock, 48, alleges the hospital and doctors Suresh Nair and David J. Bertsch, performed an unnecessary mastectomy, failed to properly assess her before and after the surgery and did not follow proper procedures when she went into cardiac arrest.
Dupnock’s husband, Michael, was seeking monetary damages to pay the $30,890 medical and funeral expenses, and an unspecified amount for the loss of his wife and the mother of their four children.
At the time of Dupnock’s death, her children were 26, 21, 13 and 11 and she was employed as a resource manager at the State Correctional Institution at Coal Township.
“We don’t want one penny for sympathy. We want justice,” said the plaintiff’s Philadelphia attorney, Gary Solomon, after describing the family’s anguish and displaying in court photos taken of Dupnock with her youngest children a few months before she died.
During the two-week trial, both sides presented numerous expert witnesses who gave conflicting testimony.
The plaintiffs said the physicians persisted in performing a mastectomy even though cancer wasn’t found in the breast after it was removed.
They alleged a drug given to Dupnock during treatment damaged her heart; cardiovascular scans were not properly performed before and did not detect the problem that caused her to stop breathing and led to her death 38 hours after surgery.
When Dupnock went into cardiac arrest in the hospital, Solomon also argued, the hospital staff did not follow protocol.
“Her cancer couldn’t be cured, but it was treatable and she could have lived for several more years,” he said, referring to expert testimony.
The defendants said Dupnock’s death was unavoidable and that she was already suffering from a rare and aggressive cancer by the time she went for treatment at Geisinger in July 2001.
Her death three months later, they said, was due to microscopic cancer cells that had spread from her breast to her brain.
Geisinger attorney, Anna Bryan, of Philadelphia, disputed the plaintiff’s claim that Dupnock was forced into having a mastectomy and described “heroic efforts” by hospital staff to save her the morning of Oct. 18, 2001.
Dr. Nair’s attorney, Mark Perry, of Scranton, said even if an MRI had been done, it would not have detected the small cancer cells that were later found in her brain during the autopsy.
He said Dupnock received appropriate care and no malpractice occurred.
Dr. Bertsch’s attorney, Daniel Robner, of Berwyn, defended his client’s decision not to continuously monitor Dupnock’s heart because she had displayed no problems in that area.
He said the physicians provided her the best treatment and care possible and should not be held to an unreasonable standard.
“It’s the practice of medicine, not the perfection of medicine. It’s an art as much as a science,” Robner said.
n E-mail comments to mmoore@dailyitem.com
News
Jury clears Geisinger in mother of four’s death
- News
-
-
Raw milk remains popular, despite illnesses
WASHINGTON — The popularity of unpasteurized raw milk remains strong despite warnings from public health officials about its dangers and outbreaks of bacterial infections. In the latest case untreated contaminated milk from a Pennsylvania farm has sickened 38 people on the East Coast. It's a reminder of the risks of consuming milk bottled straight from the cow.
-
State Supreme Court explains legislative redistricting decision
HARRISBURG — The Pennsylvania Supreme Court today explained its reasons for rejecting the state's legislative redistricting plan last week, and a justice who disagreed with the ruling said this year's races will have to be held under the existing, decade-old maps.
-
Heinz Endowments fund Flight 93 oral histories
PITTSBURGH — A project to compile oral histories of those connected to the crash of hijacked United Airlines Flight 93 will continue for at least the next three years due to a $225,000 grant from The Heinz Endowments.
-
LARA looks ahead
LEWISBURG -- The Lewisburg Community Pool and spring and summer schedule of events are the big concerns these days for those running the Lewisburg Area Recreation Authority. Officials are confident they finally have the regional recreation authority's financial situation under control.
-
Wirth not first driver to face murder charge
LEWISBURG -- Christopher Wirth isn't the first person to face a third-degree murder charge in connection with a fatal crash in Union County. "A death involving a vehicle can support third-degree murder depending on the acts of the subject," District Attorney D. Peter Johnson said Thursday.
-
Bumpy ride for prison officers
SUNBURY -- It's been a rough week for two Northumberland County Prison commanders who were suspended without pay, had their wages reinstated, were laid off and then rehired. On Monday, Brian Wheary was suspended without pay from his $36,030-a-year position as commander. By Thursday, the 37-year-old was back on the job.
-
Reality TV star ready for visit
SHAMOKIN -- Ron Shirley has never been to Shamokin, has never been to the Valley at all, but he has an idea of what's waiting for him here. "The only thing I expect is to meet friendly, honest people," said Shirley, a star of the hit Tru TV reality series, "Lizard Lick Towing."
-
Masser to seek 2nd term
ELYSBURG -- State Rep. Kurt Masser, a Republican from Elysburg, announced Thursday that he will seek a second term representing the 107th Legislative District in the state House. "I am pleased to announce that I will be seeking a second term to represent the people of our area," he said. "We've accomplished a lot in our first term, but there is so much more to do. I want to keep being an independent voice for our community in Harrisburg."
-
West Milton man arraigned on robbery charges
A West Milton man is the second suspect in an armed robbery at a West Buffalo Township convenience store Saturday night. Michael Gulli, 41, of 310 Broad St., was arrested by Milton state police who said Gulli was involved in pointing a gun at two employees of the Forest Hill Store, on Buffalo Road, in Union County, and threatening to kill them.
-
Show guns for 1,500
LEWISBURG -- Hundreds of long rifles and other Colonial weapons that helped win the Revolutionary War and forge a nation will be on display -- and some, for sale -- today through Saturday at the fifth annual 18th Century Artisan Show.
-
VIDEO: Social media command center helps Super Bowl visitors
Indianapolis is the first Super Bowl host city to utilize the power of Twitter and other social media to help football fans get the most out of football's biggest event.
-
Tim Burns drops out of U.S. Senate race
HARRISBURG — An entrepreneur from southwestern Pennsylvania is dropping out of the race for U.S. Senate now that the Republican Party has endorsed another candidate.
- More News Headlines
-
